Home > Chocolate Covered Fortune Cookies >

Traditional Vanilla Fortune Cookies - Personalized & Individually Wrapped
Traditional fortune cookies made with real vanilla! Your custom fortune cookies are baked fresh and individually wrapped for the ultimate in fresh.
Our Traditional Fortune Cookies are a natural vanilla flavored, baked fresh with real ingredients and individually wrapped. Custom fortunes are included in every order, with full color & double sided imprinting available as well.

More Views:

Important Note: Up to 5 FREE custom messages ($40.00 value) in entire order. Each additional message is $5.00 extra. Thank you!
Our Price: $0.59

Custom Fortune Cookies: Ships in 5 business days. Need them faster? Call 888-776-6611 to ask about rush service.

Type Your Custom Fortune Cookie Messages Here

Custom Fortune Cookie Messages:

Personalizing your fortune cookies is easy. Simply type your custom fortune cookie sayings into the spaces provided. Each fortune cookie saying can be 3 lines, 32 characters per line. A backslash can be used to indicate a line break. Please call if you have any questions or concerns. 888-776-6611 Thank you!
Message Themes, Logos & Custom Message Approval

Custom Approval & Stock Messages*:


Description Fortune Cookie Favors

Traditional Fortune Cookies - Each of our traditional vanilla flavored fortune cookies is made fresh right here in our bakery. We use an old fashioned fortune cookie recipe with real vanilla as the main flavoring. Our family owned bakery uses fresh eggs, flour and sugar, making our traditional cookies the best tasting fortune cookies you've ever had. Since, our vanilla fortune cookies are baked fresh, they arrive crispy and tasty at your door.

Custom Fortune Cookies Price Breaks - Buy More SAVE More!

50-99 Vanilla Fortune Cookies $0.59 each

100-499 Vanilla Fortune Cookies $0.51 each

500-999 Vanilla Fortune Cookies $0.49 each

1000-4999 Vanilla Fortune Cookies $0.45 each

5000+ Vanilla Fortune Cookies $0.39 each

Additional price breaks available. Call for a custom quote.
Important Custom Fortune Cookie Details
Traditional Fortune Cookies
• 5 Personalized Fortune Cookie Sayings Included
• Each message is 3 lines, 32 characters per line
• Additional messages just $5.00 each
• Personalized fortune cookies bake and ship in 7 business days
• All messages are mixed randomly.
• Each fortune cookie is individually wrapped in clear cello

• Your first 5 fortunes are free, after that each additional message in your order is $5 each.
• You may split your 5 free fortunes among as many as 5 different flavors—as you add each flavor to your cart, simply type which message(s) you want to be inside that flavor.
• If you do add extra fortunes, simply type them on the order page of the flavor where they belong. For example, if you want 100 lemon cookies with 5 messages and 100 orange cookies with 5 different messages, type your fortunes on the corresponding pages. The first 5 are free, so your 5 additional fortunes would total an extra $25.
• When you order additional fortunes, the extra charges will NOT be reflected in your order total. You will receive an email soon after placing your order that details the additional charge for your extra fortunes. Therefore you will see 2 separate charges on your credit card statement—one for the order itself and one just for the extra fortunes.
• We’re happy to answer any questions you may have about this—or anything else! We’re here M-F 9am—6pm Eastern time to take your call at 888-776-6611

Average Customer Review: 5 of 5 Total Reviews: 148 Write a review.

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
My Review January 18, 2017
Reviewer: Christine Marshall from Charlotte, NC United States  
Everything was great! The only thing was, one of boxes we ordered, the cookies were burnt. It still taste good, but it looked a little darker than what we usually see.
On the positive note, I called in to ask for a copy of the receipt. I spoke with Diana Rossman, she was very pleasant to speak with. She emailed me my receipts right away!

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
Gluten free January 4, 2017
Reviewer: Robert Pilling from Louisville, KY United States  
Primary reason for my order was for the gluten free cookies. We went to PF Chang's (no gluten free cookies) and my daughter had her fortune 'read' along with everybody else. The traditional cookies were for everyone else. Because I wanted the cookies right away, you sent the traditional cookies with Hanukkah fortunes (stock available?). We're not Jewish but everyone thought the fortunes were cool. My daughter took some to work and her Jewish friends thought the sentiment was nice. And the gluten free cookies tasted really good!

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
Fortune Cookies January 3, 2017
Reviewer: Catherine Blazer from Jeffersonville, IN United States  
The cookies are super cute and taste great. I am mailing this out to potential clients and plan to send those out early this  month. I am hoping for some really good feedback! I also have a marketing event coming up soon and I am thinking this might be a fun way to get people to my booth and talking.... :)

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
Delicious and the perfect gift! December 29, 2016
Reviewer: Rob in B'ton from Bloomington, IN United States  
This was my first attempt to order customized fortune cookies ... and I can confidently say that I couldn't have made a better choice than to work with Erin at Fancy Fortune Cookies! She explained everything to me in advance, helped with the planning from a timing perspective, and just made the entire process a thoroughly pleasant experience.  I will definitely be recommending Fancy Fortune Cookies to colleagues and friend ... I'll also be using them again, I'm sure!

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
Went off with a bang! December 27, 2016
Reviewer: FBC from Bozeman, MT United States  
Such a great experience! I got these well in advance of when I needed them, and they were great! I didn't realize fortune cookies actually tasted good...these taste like they are super fresh and made with good ingredients. A few cookies had broken pieces in the wrapping or were a little malformed but none were completely broken, but I'd recommend ordering a few extra if you need perfection. The min order of 50 was well above the 20 I really had to have, but I'm enjoying munching on the rest. I thought the price was reasonable for the custom turnaround and communication was smooth. I liked the font on the fortunes and the paper was higher quality. One fortune had two fortunes in it, the person was thrilled. It would be lovely to have a lower/cheaper minimum for dinner parties and such, but maybe that's not possible. Regardless, great experience and I am very happy.

Was this review helpful to you?

View All Customer Reviews