Fancy Fortune Cookies®:

Fresh-baked in Indianapolis. Custom messages. Bold colors and flavors. Real humans who answer the phone.

We’re Fancy Fortune Cookies®, a fun, family-run bakery in Indianapolis, Indiana—and we’ve been baking personalized fortune cookies (and giant fortune cookies!) since 1988.

We’re known for doing what other cookie companies can’t (or won’t): bold colors, unexpected flavors, gorgeous finishes, and custom messages that make people laugh, cry, propose, celebrate, and feel seen—all in one crunchy bite.

What we’re known for

• Custom fortunes (Your Words - Our Yum, inside jokes, brand messaging, Logos, and more)

• Bright colors + flavored cookies (we pioneered them)

• Chocolate-dipped and decorated cookies

• Giant fortune cookies for unforgettable gifts and moments

• Fast turnarounds and “yes, we can probably do that” energy

Our story: innovation, mischief, and a whole lot of joy

A gourmet fortune cookie company should have a colorful past—and we definitely do. Our founder, Mike Fry, invented the concept of flavored and colored fortune cookies and spent decades dreaming up new ways to make fortune cookies more fun, more delicious, and more unforgettable.

Today, we carry that same spirit forward—still innovating, still baking fresh, still creating custom cookies for everyone from individuals planning a party to national brands running major promotions.

Hi, I’m Erin Jump Fry (CEO + “stuntwoman”)

I’m Erin, and I’ve been a co-owner and hands-on partner in all things fortune cookie since 2005. Over the years, I’ve taken on more and more of the day-to-day leadership—sales, customer care, and helping people turn ideas into cookies that wow.

If you’ve ever thought:

• “Can we put our message inside?”

• “Can we match our brand colors?”

• “Can we make these extra dramatic?”

• “Can you help us pull this off fast?”

…you’re my people. Call us—this is what we do.

Ingredients you can taste

Our cookies are made with care and intention—fresh ingredients, thoughtfully sourced, and crafted in small batches to order. For example, we’re known for our classic vanilla cookie, and we use a higher grade of vanilla than you’d find in a typical restaurant cookie.

We avoid the “warehouse cookie” approach. Our cookies are baked fresh—because you can taste the difference.

And yes: we take chocolate seriously. You can order cookies dipped and/or drizzled in white, milk, or dark chocolate as well as caramel—and we’ve spent years refining our chocolate process to deliver a smooth, craveable bite.

The “wow” factor: giant cookies + wild custom possibilities

Want something unforgettable? Our giant fortune cookies are nearly a pound and can be customized in vibrant colors and flavors—with giant matching fortunes and full-color personalization options.

We also love building over-the-top creations (like candy-topped, candy-stuffed giants) because fortune cookies should feel like an experience, not just a dessert.